Hello all! Been a long time reader of the forums but lately would like to acquire a Seamaster to go with my Speedmaster. I've narrowed down my options to three seamasters and all are priced the same by reputable dealers in my area. They are the 2201.51 2500C PO, 2230.50 non-AC, and 2538.20 GMT. I'd like to get some advice, given that their conditions and prices are the same, what would be the best choice to buy?

Thanks!

Pictures of the watches while I tried them on:

 

Personally I would go for the PO as it looks the best, the thing is though, only you can really decide. I bought an SM 300 last week and I was sure that I was going to get the LE edition but after trying them both on I prefered the standard issue so that is the one I went with. I think trying them a few times will help you make up your mind. If you really can't decide then perhaps none of them are the watch you really want or, you have to buy all three.

 

It would be the GMT for me, but as lillatroll said...

 

Having a hard time to decide because all of them look nice

 

The co - axial because of the round bezel[emoji106]but is really what you like best

 

I would go with the PO

 

All 3 look quite large on your wrist

Is that a 42 or 45 mm PO?

 

It is a 42mm PO.

 

The 42 PO on rubber may looks a little smaller if you're having any thoughts about that

All good looking

 

Thank you all for the inputs! I got the PO! Here's a family shot...

 

Great collection! Dibs on your IWC should you ever tire and it's not paired up yet......