Hi and welcome to the forum. You were right to question the "Golden Seamaster" as it is a fairly common fake. The other one is perfectly genuine. The dial looks good, can't be certain from this photo but the movement is clean so there's a good chance the dial is ok as well. Your English is very good for a non-native speaker btw.
Edited to add: The hands on the genuine watch look too long - the minute hand should just reach the minute markers, so they may be replacements.
Click to expand...