Help about Omega Seamaster 50's

Posts
55
Likes
7
Good evening. I ask for help regarding this omega seamaster 50's. In your opinion is the dial original? Is it gold capped or plated?
Thanks in advance to those who will give their input.
 
Posts
1,175
Likes
2,461
It’s gold capped and the dial looks original. It’s been relumed however and crown/stem is damaged.
 
Posts
55
Likes
7
It’s gold capped and the dial looks original. It’s been relumed however and crown/stem is damaged.
Thank you for your quick reply. What do you think is a fair price?
 
Posts
8,630
Likes
71,368
Thank you for your quick reply. What do you think is a fair price?

As a seller or a buyer?
In either case, what’s the asking price?
 
Posts
8,630
Likes
71,368
As a buyer. Asking 850 US dollars

Others may disagree but I’m afraid that I think it’s overpriced - probably by at least $250-300.

You have to factor in a service, a new crown, lume removal and, despite the dial and hands looking good, you’re still left with a worn gold-capped 70 year old watch.

Unless you’re desperately in love with it, I’d keep on looking
 
Posts
13,483
Likes
31,778
Others may disagree but I’m afraid that I think it’s overpriced - probably by at least $250-300.

You have to factor in a service, a new crown, lume removal and, despite the dial and hands looking good, you’re still left with a worn gold-capped 70 year old watch.

Unless you’re desperately in love with it, I’d keep on looking

My thoughts too, more like a $450-$500 watch. The cold cap top is not in great shape and the re-luming hurts value considerably.
 
Posts
55
Likes
7
Others may disagree but I’m afraid that I think it’s overpriced - probably by at least $250-300.

You have to factor in a service, a new crown, lume removal and, despite the dial and hands looking good, you’re still left with a worn gold-capped 70 year old watch.

Unless you’re desperately in love with it, I’d keep on looking
It is a vintage omega seamaster and I like it precisely because it is over 70 years old. I don't understand why you say it needs a new crown?
 
Posts
8,630
Likes
71,368
On the only photo you have posted, showing the crown (with the movement), it is crooked and appears to be a different colour.

This is my 1954 Seamaster, correct crown, correct colour and on straight.

 
Posts
896
Likes
1,642
Might be worth a shot to negotiate lower given the crown stem and lume. It was going to need a service anyway. I like the dial.
Have the lume redone to match the indicie pips better.
Try for $500 no higher.
There is always another watch.
 
Posts
4,340
Likes
10,288
The area of concern is this gap. Either the crown, stem or case tube is bent. Or all of the above.

 
Posts
55
Likes
7
Excuse me, but why do you say too much work? My watchmaker takes very little time to fix the crown and I think with a good wash in the ultrasonic washing machine the case could be in very good condition. I agree the asking price is high but maybe on the $550 US I can get out of it
 
Posts
8,630
Likes
71,368
Still thinking it’s the wrong replacement crown plus all the above
 
Posts
55
Likes
7
Still thinking it’s the wrong replacement crown plus all the above
Why do you say the crown is wrong? Can you please explain?
 
Posts
50
Likes
83
Excuse me, but why do you say too much work? My watchmaker takes very little time to fix the crown and I think with a good wash in the ultrasonic washing machine the case could be in very good condition. I agree the asking price is high but maybe on the $550 US I can get out of it
People are trying to help out because that’s what you requested 😀 the crooked crown is not a great symptom, and is something that needs to be addressed at a cost, the gold capping could be in a better shape, the re-luming is so obvious you probably want that fixed aswell. Add the standard cost of a service. I would probably pass, there are lots of these that pop up on eBay and on the forum’s watch selling thread (in way better condition to be fair), but if you’re confident, as it seems, about your watchmaker’s skills, cleaning processes and the overall pricing, and you really want it go for it 👍
 
Posts
9,739
Likes
54,480
Excuse me, but why do you say too much work? My watchmaker takes very little time to fix the crown and I think with a good wash in the ultrasonic washing machine the case could be in very good condition. I agree the asking price is high but maybe on the $550 US I can get out of it
All of the issues have been mentioned. Damaged crown, gold cap in poor shape and the reluming work was poorly done. The service history is unknown, so you’ll also need to factor in the cost of a full service. This is not a rare reference. With a little patience you can find a much better example for comparable money. For example, here’s a 1956 Seamaster 2761 with a gold capped case and a perfect crosshair waffle dial that I purchased fully serviced from an eBay seller for less than the asking price on your watch.
Edited:
 
Posts
8,630
Likes
71,368
Why do you say the crown is wrong? Can you please explain?

The base of the crown (which I’ve obscured in yellow) has a conical section which is incorrect. It should sit flush against the case as does the one in my watch posted above