Forums Latest Members
  1. M'Bob Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    6,403
    Likes
    18,188
    We are getting slammed with snow in my region. A newscaster said, "We are following school closures." Is that correct...or would it be, "We are following school closings."?
     
    Mad Dog likes this.
  2. Caliber561 Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    1,474
    Likes
    2,512
    Well, both “closing” and “closure” are nouns, and they both mean about the same thing, so the two words are probably interchangeable.
     
    gostang9 and M'Bob like this.
  3. efauser I ♥ karma!!! Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    8,661
    Likes
    14,233
    In that context, I think either works.
     
    M'Bob likes this.
  4. alam Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    8,095
    Likes
    18,682
    kids out of college, stopped following school schedules, buses, closures or closings! :p
     
    Kmart, Dre, watch3s and 4 others like this.
  5. Speedy_Gonzales Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    133
    Likes
    425
    Perfectly acceptable to use closures in this context.
     
    mydeafcat, Foo2rama and M'Bob like this.
  6. blufinz52 Hears dead people, not watch rotors. Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    2,756
    Likes
    6,930
    Coming down like crazy on the NH seacoast. Arctic cold weather to follow tomorrow and Saturday ::facepalm1::
     
    M'Bob likes this.
  7. BlackTalon This Space for Rent Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    5,181
    Likes
    8,387
    I don't have no problem with neither closings or closures, too.
     
    Kmart, watch3s, Mad Dog and 3 others like this.
  8. Taddyangle Convicted Invicta Wearer Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    4,820
    Likes
    31,399
    Two kids in college; writing checks each quarter (and semester) is not coming to closure for another 2.5 years.
     
    Kmart, watch3s, Mad Dog and 6 others like this.
  9. alam Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    8,095
    Likes
    18,682
    Ha! I suggest you are prepared for those post college graduation years, for some reason they miight remain on your payroll :)
     
  10. Maganator Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    1,170
    Likes
    1,729
    Both work but I think that closure sounds better when talking about a school.
     
    mydeafcat likes this.
  11. Foo2rama Keeps his worms in a ball instead of a can. Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    17,101
    Likes
    25,346
    You can pull the Oxford Comma from my cold dead hands.
     
  12. Taddyangle Convicted Invicta Wearer Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    4,820
    Likes
    31,399
    Are we talking Seiko Sport type preparation or vintage Speedy type preparation?

    One is working on a dual degree in Engineering Physics and Mathematics, the other Economics.
     
    alam likes this.
  13. dennisthemenace Hey, he asked for it! Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    2,828
    Likes
    4,461
    They spelled skool wrongly.
     
    Mad Dog likes this.
  14. alam Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    8,095
    Likes
    18,682

    :thumbsup: good deal, your math major should keep you above water and help your vintage Speedy quest :)
     
    Taddyangle likes this.
  15. kkt Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    1,666
    Likes
    1,582
    Either is grammatically correct, but I think "closures" is the better choice. Closures suggests something out of the ordinary, while closings is what happens every day.

    https://wikidiff.com/closure/closing says:
    As nouns the difference between closing and closure
    is that closing is the act by which something is closed while closure is an event or occurrence that signifies an ending.

    Regarding the so-called Oxford Comma, yes. The question is not "Why should you put a comma before the last element in a series", the question is "Why did the AP Stylebook decide there should be a comma between every pair of elements of a series EXCEPT the last one?" Omitting the Oxford Comma is irrational and can be confusing if the elements of a series are punctuated with commas. Calling it the Oxford Comma suggests it's Oxford vs. the rest of the world; actually it's the world vs. the AP Stylebook and a few deluded copy editors who follow AP Style in other contexts.
     
    ahartfie and M'Bob like this.
  16. wsfarrell Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    2,441
    Likes
    4,133
    Closure implies a more active event, like barricades were put around the school. Closing is more passive, as in the school, which was locked up overnight, remained locked up and just didn't open. Closing is better.

    grammar_police.jpg
     
  17. gostang9 Jan 4, 2018

    Posts
    2,668
    Likes
    7,105
    I agree with the many who've said either is acceptable in this case.

    I would personally prefer 'closure' as it is a clear noun and signifies a special event (which this nasty snow-storm is). It also has a definitive and somewhat 'past-tense' interpretation, making it clear that the schools are closed and not still in the active process of 'closing'. (ie: "Children must stay home today due to the school 'closure' as a result of the snow storm.")

    'Closing' can be a noun or a verb and therefore I wouldn't use it in to describe schools that have been closed for a specific event. I would think of 'closing' more as a pending event or something currently in progress (ie: "Please leave the school as it is 'closing' soon.")
     
    M'Bob likes this.
  18. tdg2064 Jan 5, 2018

    Posts
    16
    Likes
    8
    I think the message is easily discernable, but I think closings is probably the more correct way to say it.
     
  19. dscoogs Jan 5, 2018

    Posts
    646
    Likes
    4,180
    +1. I have been assuming, correctly or incorrectly, that "closing" is normally used for physical objects (e.g. schools, roads, stores, airports etc.) and "closure" for non-physical stuff (e.g. issue/problem etc.).
     
    gatorcpa likes this.
  20. kkt Jan 5, 2018

    Posts
    1,666
    Likes
    1,582
    From online m-w.com:

    Definition of closure


    1 archaic : means of enclosing : enclosure

    2 : an act of closing : the condition of being closed

    • closure of the eyelids

    • business closures

    • the closure of the factory

    3 : something that closes

    • pocket with zipper closure

    • child-resistant closure
    (other specialized definitions omitted)
    Examples of closure in a Sentence
    1. The government forced the closure of the factory.

    2. I need to talk to him and get some closure on this issue.

    3. Going to the memorial service for his late wife made it possible for him to achieve closure.

    4. We all felt a sense of closure after our sister's murderer was sent to jail.

    5. trying to bring closure to the victim's family
    CLOSURE Defined for Kids

    Definition of closure for Students
    1 : an act of closing
    • The weather forced a closure of the schools.
    2 : the condition of being closed
    • Closure of the business has been hard on the workers.

    I would use "closure" for this case.
     
    Kmart, Longbow, Mad Dog and 1 other person like this.