Sounds like you already have all 3 straps, so in that case this discussion is moot since you can pick which ever one you want.
with that said, I don’t think #1 works at all. I think 2 and 3 are equally good, depending on the circumstances. The croc when you want to be dressy, the Cordura for more casual, sporty.
if you were traveling and having to dress both up and down and wanted to only take a single watch, then you could take those two straps and switch them out.