Gamestop frenzy

Posts
3,826
Likes
6,513
This is getting to be stupidly hilarious. Don’t argue with multi billion dollar companies?
 
Posts
18,056
Likes
27,366
This is getting to be stupidly hilarious. Don’t argue with multi billion dollar companies?
It’s Microsoft’s and Activision Blizzards among others, data and conclusions in regards to GameStop and their push to force the game buyback and resale model. I’ve sat in break out rooms at Game Developers Conference and Austin Game Conference with people on this issue.

But he can call them wrong.
 
Posts
377
Likes
442
Yes we can, actually, we tend to be very smart in the game business, and it was verified with inbox 1 time dlc. We have MBA's and lots and lots of data and tracking. But please feel free to argue with multiple billion dollar companies...
I'll believe when the other multiple billion dollar companies with very smart people who's main business is collecting data and tracking can deliver targeted ads that make me want to buy anything they're trying to sell me or even just things that are relevant. Hasn't happened yet.
 
Posts
18,056
Likes
27,366
I'll believe when the other multiple billion dollar companies with very smart people who's main business is collecting data and tracking can deliver targeted ads that make me want to buy anything they're trying to sell me or even just things that are relevant. Hasn't happened yet.
Rule number one that I tell every employee of mine. “You are not the average consumer”
 
Posts
377
Likes
442
Rule number one that I tell every employee of mine. “You are not the average consumer”
Okay, so if the data is not always right which is what you seem to be saying now. Then every 2nd user of a disc can not be labeled as a lost customer.
 
Posts
18,056
Likes
27,366
Okay, so if the data is not always right which is what you seem to be saying now. Then every 2nd user of a disc can not be labeled as a lost customer.
Your either trolling or don’t understand business.
My point is your habits and experiences are not to be used to make business decisions. Use data.
 
Posts
5,490
Likes
9,392
I'm confused. GameStop sucks because they help prevent multi-billion dollar businesses run by very smart people from earning even more?
 
Posts
2,510
Likes
3,732
I'm confused. GameStop sucks because they help prevent multi-billion dollar businesses run by very smart people from earning even more?

Well the studios are kind of the "man in the middle" - and if one AAA title doesn't perform up to expectations it can tank the whole studio.
 
Posts
18,056
Likes
27,366
I'm confused. GameStop sucks because they help prevent multi-billion dollar businesses run by very smart people from earning even more?
Multiple steps.

you have developers who make the game, publishers that market the game and provide funds for development. Investors at the developer level...

the problem is for the people that actually make the game (developers) which are often small studios not part of huge billion dollar publishers.

It all trickles down to them, they are the last to be paid, which sucks as they actually made the title.
 
Posts
5,490
Likes
9,392
Ok, so why do they work so cheaply when others profit so much off their work?
 
Posts
18,056
Likes
27,366
Ok, so why do they work so cheaply when others profit so much off their work?
Only game in town a certain points... we where in one in 2012 and back in one now.

the big boys own the online distribution and marketing channels, so in order to rise above the noise you need to be with them.

a small dev can’t even attempt to go console at this point. PC they could try if they keep scope and costs down and have great ninja marketing g and get lucky... but to do anything big with potential big rewards you need to prove your self with a mid sized title through the publishers who have the funding, to get the large funding from the publishers to afford to make and market a big title.
 
Posts
377
Likes
442
Your either trolling or don’t understand business.
My point is your habits and experiences are not to be used to make business decisions. Use data.
Data can be great but people tend to give extra weight to data that reinforces personal opinions.
 
Posts
18,056
Likes
27,366
Data can be great but people tend to give extra weight to data that reinforces personal opinions.
Yes that is why we have MBA’s and are experts in data analytics. In fact most data mining techniques and theories came from the game industry and our large amounts of data.

any data analysis on this involves looking at raw data and testing for for a hypothesis. Then you flip it and test for multiple ways that you could get that apparent response but it would actually be due to other factors. It’s only confirmed when analysis of the data proves other reasons could not be the case.

seriously we are one of the largest industries in the world. We know what we are doing.
 
Posts
377
Likes
442
Yes that is why we have MBA’s and are experts in data analytics. In fact most data mining techniques and theories came from the game industry and our large amounts of data.

any data analysis on this involves looking at raw data and testing for for a hypothesis. Then you flip it and test for multiple ways that you could get that apparent response but it would actually be due to other factors. It’s only confirmed when analysis of the data proves other reasons could not be the case.

seriously we are one of the largest industries in the world. We know what we are doing.
None of that prevents selective picking and choosing of what parts of an analysts to highlight. Especially when expectations aren't met and people need someone else to blame.
 
Posts
18,056
Likes
27,366
None of that prevents selective picking and choosing of what parts of an analysts to highlight. Especially when expectations aren't met and people need someone else to blame.
Do you really think we are that inept? That multiple extremely large publishing houses all made the same mistake independently? Something that affects the bottom line for eqch publishers to the tune of 10’s of millions of dollars if not more over a year and all titles?

esp since I already told you they ran a direct test and it supported the data with in box dlc, do I need to explain that test again? Also knowing that on modern consoles we can see when disks get transferred to new owners.

At this point I can only assume your trolling, as I’ve given clear and plausible reasoning over and over, and you think it’s different based on a gut feeling and no knowledge of the industry.

You win your right, you must have stayed at a holiday inn every night this past few days. Your smarter then the thousands of people at hundreds of companies that have looked at this issue.
 
Posts
377
Likes
442
Do you really think we are that inept? That multiple extremely large publishing houses all made the same mistake independently? Something that affects the bottom line for eqch publishers to the tune of 10’s of millions of dollars if not more over a year and all titles?

esp since I already told you they ran a direct test and it supported the data with in box dlc, do I need to explain that test again? Also knowing that on modern consoles we can see when disks get transferred to new owners.

At this point I can only assume your trolling, as I’ve given clear and plausible reasoning over and over, and you think it’s different based on a gut feeling and no knowledge of the industry.

You win your right, you must have stayed at a holiday inn every night this past few days. Your smarter then the thousands of people at hundreds of companies that have looked at this issue.
I never said inept or that it was a mistake. I said it was a choice of perspective. You can see when disk get transferred but that doesn't prove that Gamestop was involved in that transfer. I've illustrated the many of the other ways transfers happen. That's not trolling. I would disagree that you have disputed those in a plausible way. The industry doesn't like how Gamestop operates so they become the boogieman.
 
Posts
2,576
Likes
2,863
Do you really think we are that inept? That multiple extremely large publishing houses all made the same mistake independently? Something that affects the bottom line for eqch publishers to the tune of 10’s of millions of dollars if not more over a year and all titles?

esp since I already told you they ran a direct test and it supported the data with in box dlc, do I need to explain that test again? Also knowing that on modern consoles we can see when disks get transferred to new owners.

At this point I can only assume your trolling, as I’ve given clear and plausible reasoning over and over, and you think it’s different based on a gut feeling and no knowledge of the industry.

You win your right, you must have stayed at a holiday inn every night this past few days. Your smarter then the thousands of people at hundreds of companies that have looked at this issue.

I’ve been working in large multi billion $ companies (but not in the gaming industry) all my life and my experience is everyone is inept. Some are less inept than others and are able to take advantage of it.
 
Posts
806
Likes
2,108
I’ve been working in large multi billion $ companies (but not in the gaming industry) all my life and my experience is everyone is inept. Some are less inept than others and are able to take advantage of it.
I believe that’s true of almost every size and type of business. There also seems to be a universal motivation to blame outside influences for revenue shortfalls. Analysts are anything but infallible, especially when they’re all saying the same thing.