First writing believed to be 40,000 years earlier than thought

Posts
410
Likes
1,856
It was a very interesting study, they propose that the markings are likely numeric or numero-ideograhic in purpose. Which is why they compared it to the cuneiform V, IV, and III. What is novel about this research was the use of algorithims to chart the instance of repetition vs entropy, as true writing has a higher rate of entropy. In this study they found some correlation between the rates of repition and entropy between cuneiform V and the Aurignacian symbol system. The authors do admit that calling these marks writing is a stretch:
"In sum, the sign sequences of the Swabian Aurignacian might be described as human intercommunication by means of conventional visible marks, while they certainly do not meet the criterion of writing sensu strictu."
This is interesting, why does true writing have a higher rate of entropy and if you could define entropy in this case because I think I know what that means but I’m not sure.
 
Posts
3,948
Likes
11,021
This is interesting, why does true writing have a higher rate of entropy and if you could define entropy in this case because I think I know what that means but I’m not sure.
Let's start by defining entropy in the way these language researchers are using it: in this case entropy is simply how often a symbol (or word) is repeated within a sample. So, the modern language sample in the table you shared earlier the TeDDi (Text Data Diversity) has higher rates of entropy and lower rates of repetition because we are communicating more complex ideas.

In the Uruk V samples you see a much higher rate of repetition and lower rate of entropy because it's mostly communicating numeric values and has fewer instances of ideographs. As cuneiform became more sophisticated in Uruk IV and Uruk III more and more ideographs started to be used to communicate more complicated information.

The researchers, after using these three series of cuneiform and several modern languages as their control group, ran these and the Aurignacian symbols through their algorithm. The researchers found that the Aurignacian symbols and Uruk V had similar rates for both repetition and entropy. This leads them to believe that the Aurignacian symbols were communicating similar information to what is found in Uruk V proto-cunieform.
 
Posts
2,566
Likes
3,729
Let's start by defining entropy in the way these language researchers are using it: in this case entropy is simply how often a symbol (or word) is repeated within a sample. So, the modern language sample in the table you shared earlier the TeDDi (Text Data Diversity) has higher rates of entropy and lower rates of repetition because we are communicating more complex ideas.

In the Uruk V samples you see a much higher rate of repetition and lower rate of entropy because it's mostly communicating numeric values and has fewer instances of ideographs. As cuneiform became more sophisticated in Uruk IV and Uruk III more and more ideographs started to be used to communicate more complicated information.

The researchers, after using these three series of cuneiform and several modern languages as their control group, ran these and the Aurignacian symbols through their algorithm. The researchers found that the Aurignacian symbols and Uruk V had similar rates for both repetition and entropy. This leads them to believe that the Aurignacian symbols were communicating similar information to what is found in Uruk V proto-cunieform.
And now my little brain hurts. I just may need a drink. Thanks guys😂🤣
 
Posts
1,533
Likes
3,182
A number of kills, like the missions count on your plane, could also be an explanation for those marks on the ivory object.
 
Posts
4,737
Likes
47,590

No I think sheepsdoll got it right it's actually a menu planner for the month though to be sure it's a little boring, shoulder roast for much of the month followed by Ribs later in the month.
Perhaps this was the equivalent of a restaurant menu and in reality the cave system where this was found was today's equivalent of a mall restaurant. Clever chaps these Neandatalls perhaps it was a franchise operation if so more discoveries to come from other locations😀