Finally came in! Should I remove the protective plastics?

Posts
16,305
Likes
45,005
Thanks, but I am quite familiar with Delrin and it's properties. I've bought enough of it for conveyor wear strips in my years in engineering to make a million brakes for Speedmasters. I know watch collectors love to make a big deal of this being some very special plastic, but like all plastics it has a particular set of properties that make it either suitable or unsuitable for different applications.

For example for wear strips I found it more useful than UHMW-PE because it was less likely to absorb oils and change dimensions (expand) and that caused a lot of problems with jammed up conveyors. But in other applications, UHMW-PE was better. In engineering, it wasn't seen as anything special, just another option out of many available to you depending on what was needed.

To me the "Delrin" brake (along with the "Hesalite" crystal) is sort of the "904L stainless" of Omega. People read far too much into it...
I know you are familiar with it Al, I posted that for those who don’t know what it is and are reading this.

Your statement of “ Delrin isn't anything special when it comes to plastics” just makes it sound like it’s no better than the plastic used in water bottles- whereas it is suited for specific engineering applications. Just don’t want people thinking this was a “cost cutting” measure and because plastic was used in a watch movement, it’s “cheap”.
 
Posts
29,914
Likes
77,361
Your statement of “ Delrin isn't anything special when it comes to plastics” just makes it sound like it’s no better than the plastic used in water bottles- whereas it is suited for specific engineering applications.

A water bottle is a specific and rather demanding engineering application. Again, plastics have different properties that make them suitable for different applications. The fact that one application is for a container and one for a stop lever in a watch movement, doesn't mean that the plastic used for the container is somehow inferior. I'm guessing that Delrin would make a terrible water bottle.

Just don’t want people thinking this was a “cost cutting” measure and because plastic was used in a watch movement, it’s “cheap”.

Okay? Should I not point out that this blocking lever is less than half the cost of the two piece steel version then? Or that they they both perform equally?

😉
 
Posts
16,305
Likes
45,005
Or that they they both perform equally?

😉
That was simply the distinction I wanted to make. Your opinion carries a lot of weight here so I just wanted to clarify that the use of plastic in this application was a decision made based on the properties of that specific material and is not “lesser”.
 
Posts
29,914
Likes
77,361
That was simply the distinction I wanted to make. Your opinion carries a lot of weight here so I just wanted to clarify that the use of plastic in this application was a decision made based on the properties of that specific material and is not “lesser”.

Decisions like this always have more than one consideration. The two most important are performance and price, and I'm sure both were a factor here.

There's no doubt that the plastic single part is cheaper to make than two steel parts. There would be a rather large investment up front making the injection molding dies, but once you have those you can pump these out very quickly and easily. You now only have one sku instead of two for the same function (leaving the spare parts supply aside).

Does this mean the plastic brake doesn't work as well? No, there's no indication of that, but it also doesn't work any better.

Things like plastics and adhesives are part of watchmaking. In fact adhesives have been for centuries, in the form of shellac. Today that is still used, but it also accompanied by other more modern adhesives - the one that comes to mind is gluing of the balance spring into the stud, instead of pinning it. These things are definitely done to cut costs, but they also perform fine.
 
Posts
7,724
Likes
14,298
It seems in the Omega collector world of plastics: Delrin = cheap ass, Hesalite = supremely good.
 
Posts
249
Likes
386
Remember to grease both sides of the discs, so the pads get a good grip. This will also prevent corrosion 😜
Edited: