Actually, both dials look good to me, especially the black guilloche. The one on the left needs a proper crown. The one on the right has the correct style of crown, but it should be gold plated, not steel. Either one would be a nice addition to a collection.
I don't think you can generalize too much on the shape of the "S" as there were multiple fonts used on these early Seamasters.
All comes down to the price, I suppose,
gatorcpa
Click to expand...