Excellent Condition?

Posts
1,105
Likes
552
You start saying polar, bluesy, explorer 1, batman, kermit, etc. and then you say patina, tropical, cream, panda, McQueen, etc.
 
Posts
402
Likes
351
These blue dials are "galvanic" a type of electrolytic plating. They are not painted.
I just did some reading about crazing of anodic surfaces, and it explains a great deal of what we are seeing and where it happens. It is a breakdown of the anodic surface either through stress (pressing a shape into a piece of metal captures energy in that piece of metal for example) or heat which affects the hardness of the anodized surface. I know that there is a lot more to understand, but I love that this forum sends me down these kinds of bunny holes.
 
Posts
7,694
Likes
26,669
I've posted this previously, but it may help some newer members to interpret various sellers' claims 😁:

For the benefit of those who have not yet figured out the precise meanings of words used to describe watches being sold, I've put together a handy quick reference guide:

RARE = obscure, and probably undesirable

MINTY = leaves a fresh feeling in your mouth if you suck on it for several minutes (remember though: sucking on a non-waterproof watch could cause damage to the timepiece; conversely, the safer diver's models tend to be very big, and the large crowns may scrape sensitive tissue)

VINTAGE = manufactured sometime prior to 2005

CLASSIC = smaller than 40mm (without crown)

REDUCED = the seller either initially priced the item ridiculously high, or it's unlikely to be sold at any price

REDUCED AGAIN = see above (and probably the latter)

FINAL REDUCTION = seller will probably accept 70% of the stated "final" price, and pay postage plus the Paypal fee

SPRING CLEANING = seller will likely accept $50.00 for the whole lot

STUNNING = just remember that's it's quite possible to be stunned by ugliness

BEAUTIFUL = perhaps in the eye of the beholder, who happens to be the seller

COLLECTIBLE = somebody in the world owns more than one

IMPORTANT = to the seller, as bills are due

NOS = excellent condition, but with various "storage" marks

MINT = excellent condition (at best)

EXCELLENT = very good condition (at best)

VERY GOOD = good condition (at best)

GOOD = fair condition (at best)

FAIR = unsalvageable condition

Finally, for most efficient browsing, keep the following tip in mind: the more exclamation points there are following a description, the less likely it is to be accurate!
Edited:
 
Posts
11,632
Likes
20,338
These blue dials are "galvanic" a type of electrolytic plating. They are not painted.

I didn’t know that - good to know.

The point remains, the process used to create these blue dials during the late 60’s/early 70’s very often leads to the degradation shown here.
 
Posts
13,046
Likes
52,017
The fractal (ish) edges in the Rolex dial damage are interesting. Very cheeky to expect a premium ….
 
Posts
240
Likes
257
It is kind of a shame that the early Tudor and Rolex blue dials were prone to the dial damage. I can't remember where I saw it, but I remember being tempted by a WG 1803 with a blue buckley dial. Alas, was also afflicted.
 
Posts
1,320
Likes
7,886
Blue dials from Rolex (and other brands) in the late 60s and the 70s were prone to this "flaking" effect. On Datejusts, it is typically found on the edge of the pie-pan dial.

Here is my blue "Buckley" Datejust with a similar effect.


That said, some examples did in fact make it into the 21st century without seeing such degradation. Here is my near perfect example of a blue mosaic Datejust.
 
Posts
1,105
Likes
552
I've posted this previously, but it may help some newer members to interpret various sellers' claims 😁:

For the benefit of those who have not yet figured out the precise meanings of words used to describe watches being sold, I've put together a handy quick reference guide:

RARE = obscure, and probably undesirable

MINTY = leaves a fresh feeling in your mouth if you suck on it for several minutes (remember though: sucking on a non-waterproof watch could cause damage to the timepiece; conversely, the safer diver's models tend to be very big, and the large crowns may scrape sensitive tissue)

VINTAGE = manufactured sometime prior to 2005

CLASSIC = smaller than 40mm (without crown)

REDUCED = the seller either initially priced the item ridiculously high, or it's unlikely to be sold at any price

REDUCED AGAIN = see above (and probably the latter)

FINAL REDUCTION = seller will probably accept 70% of the stated "final" price, and pay postage plus the Paypal fee

SPRING CLEANING = seller will likely accept $50.00 for the whole lot

STUNNING = just remember that's it's quite possible to be stunned by ugliness

BEAUTIFUL = perhaps in the eye of the beholder, who happens to be the seller

COLLECTIBLE = somebody in the world owns more than one

IMPORTANT = to the seller, as bills are due

NOS = excellent condition, but with various "storage" marks

MINT = excellent condition (at best)

EXCELLENT = very good condition (at best)

VERY GOOD = good condition (at best)

GOOD = fair condition (at best)

FAIR = unsalvageable condition

Finally, for most efficient browsing, keep the following tip in mind: the more exclamation points there are following a description, the less likely it is to be accurate!

As mr.dealer 😁
 
Posts
64
Likes
240
What shall we call this? Algae patina? Seaweed patina? Christmas wreath patina? EKG patina?
Solar eclipse patina.
 
Posts
637
Likes
1,143
This is my 63 Seastar, you can see the 11 is coming away and a bit of a speckle dial. That’s the blue from the era and how it was done.
When wearing it you can barely tell but zoomed in it doesn’t look the best. Comes with vintage watches and that sort of dial I’m afraid.
I had a blue dial C shape Connie that was about to start doing the same thing. What can you do.
 
Posts
1,579
Likes
5,082
What shall we call this? Algae patina? Seaweed patina? Christmas wreath patina? EKG patina?
"The ring of fire"
 
Posts
530
Likes
2,300
That watch is beautiful, everything except for the dial.

Celtics are dead to me - they blew that.
 
Posts
67
Likes
42
That watch is in average shape other than the dial. Excellent (or even good) shouldn't be anywhere near that listing. I hate it when sellers list things as "mint" or excellent quality with obvious flaws. Excellent condition should have zero signs of wear other than faint scratches.