You're catering to the average eBay buyer who knows nothing of the vintage market. They just want a pretty watch to wear, and maybe show it off at a barbecue or party saying how old it is to their friends that also know nothing other than it's old and they know the brand name. This is a site full of collectors. Nobody here would buy that blue dialed ....... whatever you want to call it.
First of all, if I see 9.5 out of 10 that means it's retains 95% of it's ORIGINALITY. Collectors will agree that the dial of a vintage watch is 30% to 40% of a watch's value. Let's be on the light side and say that watch is 7 out of 10 for the refinished dial - and that's being generous because it isn't true to the original color. Second, the case has been reworked a bit. The person who did it obviously knew what they were doing, but it isn't original anymore. Again I'll be generous and only knock off 1 mark so it's 6 /10 now. Third, the movement has had some water damage. This is why the original dial's paint was so bad it had to be refinished. I can see the places where the verdigris has been removed from the movement during service. Let's be generous one more time and knock a half point off so it's 5.5 / 10 now - and you'd get a worse assessment from many. The 1 to 10 scale for vintage watches does NOT mean how pretty & shiny it is after redialing & polishing, it refers to how much of the original finish and case crispness the watch retains.
Long story short: no collector would even look twice at that once they saw the dial, and I don't even mean up close - the blatant color would be offensive.
If you want to cater to your usual customer who doesn't know any better than it's your business and there certainly are enough buyers to keep you and many other sellers in business. I get it - you can buy ugly watches from decent brands and redo them to make a profit. However, if you want to get TOP dollar (like Alex in Mexico does) you need the cream of the crop in original specimens. The real collectors do look for bargains, but we also will pay double or triple market for an near mint example of an uncommon or legitimately rare watch.
Click to expand...