Community Stories

Dogleg piepan: Repainted or original?!

hant26
Posts
324
Likes
672
Hello everyone, I just found this one today. It looks good but maybe the piepan edge doesn’t look sharp. Should I take it or let it pass?! Pls let me know your opinion on whether the dial is original or repainted. Thank you
IMG_1352.webp IMG_1353.webp IMG_1357.webp IMG_1354.webp IMG_1356.webp IMG_1355.webp
Edited:
 
Dan S
Posts
21,471
Likes
48,766
Fancy photos. What are your specific concerns based on comparisons with other examples?
 
hant26
Posts
324
Likes
672
That’s all the photos I have. I just want to know your opinion!?
 
Puma_135o
Posts
241
Likes
404
I don't know if it's repainted or not. I like it. This means that the fonts seem correct, I don't see misalignments.
Edited:
 
hant26
Posts
324
Likes
672
hoipolloi hoipolloi
Are you sure it is a 168.005?
No. I haven’t seen the case back. But that doesn’t matter. Do you see any problem on the dial?!
Edited:
 
hoipolloi
Posts
3,657
Likes
6,187
hant26 hant26
No. I haven’t seen the case back. But that doesn’t matter. Do you see any problem on the dial?!
Yes
 
hoipolloi
Posts
3,657
Likes
6,187
hant26 hant26
You said " something is off". That means you have seen something is not right.
Now is the time for you to sharpen your skill by looking at all the details that you have not looked at yet.
Good luck.
 
hant26
Posts
324
Likes
672
hoipolloi hoipolloi
Now is the time for you to sharpen your skill by looking at all the details that you have not looked at yet.
Good luck.
Well I think the piepan edge seems blur so maybe the dial has been repainted. And the minute marker No.33 is diffirent than the others. But in general, the repaint job was done quite well.
Edited:
 
gatorcpa
Posts
12,693
Likes
17,147
I don’t think the pictures have enough definition to make a determination. When I blow up the 33 minute marker, I can’t tell if there is dirt on the dial or a bad repaint. Could be either.

That is why one needs to purchase a watch like this either on person or on approval with a full return provision.
gatorcpa
 
hant26
Posts
324
Likes
672
Right. Those photos aren’t good enough to see all detail. I will ask for better resolution photos or to meet directly then
 
Peemacgee
Posts
5,641
Likes
8,740
@hant26
It’s not always a zero sum game.

You don’t need better pics or to see the watch in person.
There doesn’t appear to be anything wrong with the dial IMHO

But

Either
The movt doesn’t belong to the case and dial
Or
The dial doesn’t belong to the case and movt.

Look at the movt serial number and closely at the indices.
That will tell you why.
 
hoipolloi
Posts
3,657
Likes
6,187
Peemacgee Peemacgee
There doesn’t appear to be anything wrong with the dial IMHO
Have you compared the sizes of the letters on those three lines?
Screenshot_20241115_045308_Gallery.webp
 
Dan S
Posts
21,471
Likes
48,766
Peemacgee Peemacgee
@hant26
It’s not always a zero sum game.

You don’t need better pics or to see the watch in person.
There doesn’t appear to be anything wrong with the dial IMHO

But

Either
The movt doesn’t belong to the case and dial
Or
The dial doesn’t belong to the case and movt.

Look at the movt serial number and closely at the indices.
That will tell you why.
I think I am in danger of learning something from this thread! 😀
 
gatorcpa
Posts
12,693
Likes
17,147
Peemacgee Peemacgee
Either
The movt doesn’t belong to the case and dial
Or
The dial doesn’t belong to the case and movt.

Look at the movt serial number and closely at the indices.
That will tell you why
Do you think that the dial has painted indices? I really can't tell from the pictures.

Since we don't have pictures of the caseback or reference, I can neither agree nor disagree with you.

hoipolloi hoipolloi
Have you compared the sizes of the letters on those three lines?
Show me a head-on picture without a crystal and then I can compare.

Let's not play games with this anymore. It's not fair to the OP.

Do what they say, say what they mean. (One thing...one thing leads to another! - The Fixx).
gatorcpa
 
hoipolloi
Posts
3,657
Likes
6,187
gatorcpa gatorcpa
Do you think that the dial has painted indices? I really can't tell from the pictures.

Since we don't have pictures of the caseback or reference, I can neither agree nor disagree with you.


Show me a head-on picture without a crystal and then I can compare.

Let's not play games with this anymore. It's not fair to the OP.

Do what they say, say what they mean. (One thing...one thing leads to another! - The Fixx).
gatorcpa
Looks like you are too old and your eyes are not sharp anymore.
The sellers who sell redialed or frankened watches never give you a clear and head on picture to look at.
You have to dig deep into details behind those small signs.
 
gatorcpa
Posts
12,693
Likes
17,147
hoipolloi hoipolloi
The sellers who sell redialed or frankened watches never give you a clear and head on picture to look at.
Which is why I keep saying you have to see it in person.
gatorcpa
 
Peemacgee
Posts
5,641
Likes
8,740
hoipolloi hoipolloi
Have you compared the sizes of the letters on those three lines?
Screenshot_20241115_045308_Gallery.webp
to be honest, I was looking on my phone and took any variation to be the angle of the image.
'automatic' does look larger than 'chronometer'
why would a redialler get everything else pretty much spot on and miss that detail?

Either way, redial or replacement dial, the dial doesn't belong with the movt.
 
Peemacgee
Posts
5,641
Likes
8,740
gatorcpa gatorcpa
Do you think that the dial has painted indices? I really can't tell from the pictures.

Since we don't have pictures of the caseback or reference, I can neither agree nor disagree with you.


Show me a head-on picture without a crystal and then I can compare.

Let's not play games with this anymore. It's not fair to the OP.

Do what they say, say what they mean. (One thing...one thing leads to another! - The Fixx).
gatorcpa

Even on a phone you can clearly see that the indices are painted - or at least not onyx inserts.

For my part, I don't think anyone is playing games.
I tried to point out to the OP that the simple, single question they were asking wasn't the right approach.
Whether the dial is redialled or a good replacement, it doesn't belong with the movement in the watch, no matter the case reference - and he doesn't need to see the watch in person to ascertain that.
I pointed the OP to the mismatched parts and I don't think it is unreasonable for them to look into why they are mismatched - that's how we all learn.


Screenshot 2024-11-15 at 08.53.19.webp
 
2 More Posts...
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

M

Fake, repainted or original?? Any reason to believe this vintage pie pan is fake?

Mbenge Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
Pvt-Public
Pvt-Public
Posts
14
Views
3K
vonrozen

Hands repainted or original ?

vonrozen Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
perenowell
perenowell
Posts
4
Views
746
nanjingcigaretes

1973 Omega Constellation Dogleg Piepan Ref. 168.0065 - Eur 1400

nanjingcigaretes Watches For Sale
nanjingcigaretes
nanjingcigaretes
Posts
6
Views
7K
nanjingcigaretes

Omega Constellation 168.005 Dogleg Piepan Crosshair -REDUCED EUR 1500

nanjingcigaretes Private Watch Sales
nanjingcigaretes
nanjingcigaretes
Posts
9
Views
19K
N

Is this a refurbished dial or original dial for an Omega Speedmaster 145.014 Racing Dial?

nicizz Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
N
nicizz
Posts
10
Views
4K
Peter_from_NL

Constellation dial repainted or original?

Peter_from_NL Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
BDHD
BDHD
Posts
3
Views
715