Guys... which would you prefer?

 

Mil Sub. I know they're sought after, but I dislike the Comex logo across the dial.

(Not that I'd turn one down if offered...)

 

+1 for Mil Sub

I'd love to be in a position where this was the decision that I had to make. GL

 

+2 for mil sub. No brainier. It's a grail piece; much more expensive than Comex.

 

That mil Sub lume has me wondering ...

Comex is always a good choice.

Such a mine field because of the prices, I prefer to play elsewhere.

 

I don't know- I've seen them equally priced. Right around 100k. Maybe it was an overpriced comex. I agree- the 5513 is as cool as is gets. One can only imagine what that watch has seen.

 

To wear? Neither. A nice 551x or 1680 suffices.

 

Isnt that the fun of collecting? They are both great conversations pieces.

 

Mil sub undoubtedly

 

I admit to knowing little about these but is the hour hand on the milsub correct and original to the watch? It just looks a little off to me

 

Unless he's buying the mil sub from James Dowling I don't believe that the image is of the specific military submariner he's considering..

 

The Comex Sub pic above looks suspect too - Bezel insert looks wrong, dial print looks wrong and there is no rubber o ring on the crown tube...Wrong!

 

Milsub gets my vote too, I think it has more mystique.
Buster

 

I like both but for me the MilSub wins hands down.

 

+1

 

Mil Sub definitely... I can't remember where I put these 100k by the way...

 

Be different.
Find a W10

 

Mil sub for me too.

 

Of the 2 pictured; The Milsub.