I think he feels you may be missing the point. The original paint is everything, it's the art, it's the soul. The piece of metal dial is no different than the artists' canvas.
If you took the Mona Lisa and stripped all the paint off and repainted it, technically, you still have in your possession the Mona Lisa, but the art and the artists' soul is destroyed, reduced to a pile of material.
This is how collectors feel about repainted dials. We mourn what has been lost.
Click to expand...