Just back home after spending the day running around.
So, here's where I'm at: I read everything I could find last night. I genuinely lost sleep (and was happy to be tired) at the thought of finding a rarity like this, misdescribed, in a lot with another watch. I understand it's a partial re-dial. I think that the hands are correct; that the logo on the dial is also correct (it's in the right position in relation to the minute track) but I was confident in saying that it was reprinted if only because of the hash at the 12 on the subdial and the way the marks sit inside the rim. The concentric circles in the subdial are clearly visible, though.
I found the following images from the 1938 catalogue on the MWR website:
Posted with these were the following words:
when I posted the three images from the 1937 Italian catalog I certainly did not pretend to be exhaustive. I'm not sure that other dial designs than the ones in this catalog should be automatically disqualified, we know that there were then many dial variations and not all of them were pictured in the catalogs. The ones pictured there were the ones available at the Italian exclusive distributor for 1937, but other designs may have been available elsewhere and/or for other years. In addition, the same model was still present in the 1940 catalog of the same Italian distributor, showing the cadrante 20, but under reference 728. Moreover it is on the calibre 30mm page, but I think it was still a 26.5 inside (this just to say that those catalogs are sometimes approximative).
When I looked up the poster, the screen name was very similar to our own
@Tire-comedon who's already been tagged into the thread.
So, where I'm at and what I'm struggling with is that I accept that the dial has been redone ... but how bad is it? I've rolled the dice on this one. I've paid for it. I'm genuinely happy at whatever the consensus because, frankly, I think this was cheap. I don't know how many members here have experience of this watch. Personally, before last night I've seen two photographs. I had a finite period of time to decide and I went for it.
Click to expand...