Automatic v Manual Wind?

Posts
1,011
Likes
419
I prefer a manual watch because it's easier to wind up to full throttle than a automatic .
 
Posts
15,048
Likes
24,057
I prefer a manual watch because it's easier to wind up to full throttle than a automatic .
How so?
 
Posts
1,011
Likes
419
Probably me that is a little slow. I don't move around so much that an automatic gets fully wind up.
Edited:
 
Posts
15,048
Likes
24,057
Probably me that is a little slow. I don't move around so much that an oj
In most cases you can wind your automatic watch, just like you do your manual watch.
 
Posts
1,011
Likes
419
Sorry my phone is stupid. Will answer your question tomorrow. On my computer instead.
 
Posts
17,939
Likes
37,516
This one is not really a multi-rotor, three weights going around the center but cool to watch.

I was waiting for that, but I expected the Corum to pop up before the Paul Gerber
 
Posts
1,011
Likes
419
In most cases you can wind your automatic watch, just like you do your manual watch.
That is just the point .Why wind a automatic when it's suppose to be automatic?. As i don't use the same watch every day and don't have a winder . The automatic watch stops after a day or two .When i like to wear a automatic watch I take it up and it start ticking . Set the time and date . Wear it all day and then when you go to bed .Put it on your bedtable . It's stops during the night . Why ? Because it's not wind up enough . A manual you can wind up and it goes for two or more days . An automatic watch u need to have on your wrist every day to keep it fully wind . An automatic needs more service is more complex then a manual .
 
Posts
1,320
Likes
739
When i like to wear a automatic watch I take it up and it start ticking . Set the time and date . Wear it all day and then when you go to bed .Put it on your bedtable . It's stops during the night . Why ? Because it's not wind up enough .

That seems very odd. All of my old bumper automatics will be wound enough during a day's use to make it through the night, still ticking away happily. And that is from stopped, without doing any manual winding at all.
 
Posts
1,011
Likes
419
Me not moving around that much ? Deskjob . The watch was a Planet ocean and a Omega 50 annevarsary Seamaster .Newly serviced . See now point in have to wind up by hand .
 
Posts
2,921
Likes
14,963
TWhen i like to wear a automatic watch I take it up and it start ticking . Set the time and date . Wear it all day and then when you go to bed .Put it on your bedtable . It's stops during the night . Why ? Because it's not wind up enough .

Funny, I'm not a particularly active guy but I don't have this problem that's been described. On most watches with a power reserve of 38-42 hours, I wear the watch for about 12 hours a day, and it seems fully wound. Which means I take it off Mon night 8pm, and the PR keeps it going till I pick it up again Wed 8am (ie. 36 hours in between). Seems to work whether vintage or modern, so it allows me to alternate watches without using a winder.
 
Posts
7,337
Likes
25,624
That seems very odd. All of my old bumper automatics will be wound enough during a day's use to make it through the night, still ticking away happily. And that is from stopped, without doing any manual winding at all.

Funny, I'm not a particularly active guy but I don't have this problem that's been described. On most watches with a power reserve of 38-42 hours, I wear the watch for about 12 hours a day, and it seems fully wound. Which means I take it off Mon night 8pm, and the PR keeps it going till I pick it up again Wed 8am (ie. 36 hours in between). Seems to work whether vintage or modern, so it allows me to alternate watches without using a winder.
+1, I have the same experience with my automatics...maybe you're automatics need
servicing Rogart, or you're dead.😉
 
Posts
1,011
Likes
419
+1, I have the same experience with my automatics...maybe you're automatics need
servicing Rogart, or you're dead.😉
Not dead yet i hope . The watch was newly serviced . That is only i my experience . And why i prefer manual watches over automatics . @NT931 have you ever tried it on a completely empty watch that has stopped . Wear it for a day and put it on bedtable . Does it go all night ? No winding crown just shake it so much it starts working . Set the hands and date if there is . Does it wind up so much that it's fully wind and go for 48 hours ?
 
Posts
6,832
Likes
13,797
Love both, but if you told me I could never manually wind a watch again I would Cry. If you told me there are no more automatics I would just work out my fingers a little more. It is a very nice ritual, one I saw my father doing every day, and one I like to do myself.

It's like shaking hands with my watch every morning...
 
Posts
2,921
Likes
14,963
@NT931 have you ever tried it on a completely empty watch that has stopped . Wear it for a day and put it on bedtable . Does it go all night ? No winding crown just shake it so much it starts working . Set the hands and date if there is . Does it wind up so much that it's fully wind and go for 48 hours ?
Yup, I can safely say that if I set the time, then shake an auto watch to get it going in the morning, then wear it for at least 8 hours, the PR builds up to conservatively around 30-32 hours. So yeah, it definitely lasts throughout the night. Seems to last a bit longer if I wind it first though.

For my only auto watch with a PR indicator, I know that with 7-8 hours of wear, the PR is full at 45h. No problems there at all, as you can see from this earlier post of mine - PR is full by 5.30pm.
 
Posts
2,921
Likes
14,963
How many times to you have to wind it to get a full charge?
Not sure as I can never really tell if I've done a full turn - did i turn it 360 degrees? 300? But I estimate about 30 turns perhaps?
 
Posts
1,023
Likes
762
Last watch I had trouble with was a 1 year old purchased from the boutique Tag Aquaracer. Suddenly is was an hour behind every day. I sent it in, fully covered under warranty but in fact a spring problem. It wasn't holding the power reserve anymore.
Waiting for the watch to come back rebuilt and polished like new. Planned to put it up for sale before wearing it, and use the money for a new Omega.
 
Posts
586
Likes
655
The reason I bought the 3570.50 Speedy from Kring was history, design and manual wind. Winding this watch for some reason gives me great enjoyment (and I have a mental picture of my 20 year old son rolling his eyes at me). 😁
 
Posts
509
Likes
316
I like both and I would think when service is needed the Manual would be a little cheaper?
 
Posts
127
Likes
15
i also like both... its makes no difference if you have multiple watches and wear every day another one...