Community Stories

Anybody ever consigned a vintage watch with Hodinkee?

BlueOtter
Posts
49
Likes
83
Hi,

Has anyone on this forum ever consigned a vintage watch with Hodinkee? I know that in most vintage watch forums, Hodinkee is not well liked (because of the very fact that they've had many shady watches for sale in the past), but surely from a consignor's perspective, the experience can't be that terrible? - their watches always trade at a premium, and they items seem to move really quick. I am in no way supporting Hodinkee shop, but am simply curious as to how their consignment process is like, and if there are a lot of hidden costs and fees involved.

Would appreciate it if anybody can share their experiences. Thank you.
 
janice&fred
Posts
4,593
Likes
10,810
BlueOtter BlueOtter
Hodinkee is not well liked (because of the very fact that they've had many shady watches for sale in the past),

BlueOtter BlueOtter
the experience can't be that terrible?

BlueOtter BlueOtter
their watches always trade at a premium


well it sure looks like the experience could be risky for the buyer no?
 
STANDY
Posts
16,863
Likes
47,901
Know a few people that have, will let them come forward.


Have you asked Hodinkee for their terms of business.
 
ryankelly
Posts
66
Likes
187
EDIT - completely misread the OP, which was about consignment and not purchase. Apologies.
Edited:
 
BlueOtter
Posts
49
Likes
83
janice&fred janice&fred
well it sure looks like the experience could be risky for the buyer no?

There definitely is some risk for the buyer, and that I acknowledge. But then again, they also seem to have a comprehensive no questions asked return policy that runs for about a week - and it looks like that could mitigate the risks, albeit not to the full extent.

On the other hand, what I am curious to know is the consignor's perspective.
 
asrnj77
Posts
1,487
Likes
2,376
Not sure if it’s changed but I believe they take 20% commission so something to consider when selling. I guess in the grand scheme of things eBay takes close to 14% with taxes and if Hodinkee takes your consignment it will sell within a week so might not be all that bad. My understanding is that they’ll only take what they think they can sell so you’d have to contact them first
 
BlueOtter
Posts
49
Likes
83
asrnj77 asrnj77
Not sure if it’s changed but I believe they take 20% commission so something to consider when selling. I guess in the grand scheme of things eBay takes close to 14% with taxes and if Hodinkee takes your consignment it will sell within a week so might not be all that bad. My understanding is that they’ll only take what they think they can sell so you’d have to contact them first

Doesn't sound like the worst thing to be fair. Most auction houses take a similar commission, with additional costs such as photography.
 
jhross98
Posts
1,294
Likes
2,299
I've sold watches through hodinkee. They are very particular in what they'll take (and its hard to know what they're looking for). If it doesn't sell quickly you get the watch back. But I was very happy with where I ended up. . my general view is you will do better on consignment with good examples of less liquid vintage watches than you will on say an ebay and Hodinkee is amongst the best places to consign (if they'll take your watch)
 
thelinendial
Posts
398
Likes
405
janice&fred janice&fred
well it sure looks like the experience could be risky for the buyer no?

Wow! That's surprising that they would mistake authentic watches given what they're supposed to stand for.
 
BlueOtter
Posts
49
Likes
83
jhross98 jhross98
I've sold watches through hodinkee. They are very particular in what they'll take (and its hard to know what they're looking for). If it doesn't sell quickly you get the watch back. But I was very happy with where I ended up. . my general view is you will do better on consignment with good examples of less liquid vintage watches than you will on say an ebay and Hodinkee is amongst the best places to consign (if they'll take your watch)

Thank you for the insight. It's been very helpful.
 
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

thelinendial

Any Experience Restoring a Vintage Watch with Original Service Center in Switzerland?

thelinendial Longines Watches
thelinendial
thelinendial
Posts
16
Views
5K