The gasket that will fit that case is an "O" ring gasket that is a perfect fit in the groove around the case opening. It must be of the right diameter, and the exact circumference, and must be lubricated with silicon grease. Then, use your dedicated Rolex Oyster case wrench to tighten the case back. Then, put the watch into your waterproof tester to assure it is water tight. The short answer is, take it to a watchmaker who has what is needed to do the job right!