224105: what to relume

Posts

6,499

Likes

10,179

Mark020

·Oct 31, 2020·not the sharpest pencil in the ΩF drawer

I know, I know: only original once. Fact is that the hands of this one are for sure not original lume and I have my doubts about the rest. Idea is to send the hands to James Hyman anyway but what about the rest? The longer I look at the lume the more doubts I have. Some pics: (also - for fun - James' recent work on a 1016)

Edited: Oct 31, 2020

 

Posts

16,307

Likes

44,994

JwRosenthal

·Oct 31, 2020

Can’t speak to the debate on the UG, but that explorer dial should be archived as an example of absolutely when to relume. Stunning outcome!

 

Posts

3,587

Likes

8,281

bgrisso

·Oct 31, 2020

Tough to say on the left, dial could be original lume. I would only relume the dial if the dark color really bothers you. You could probably go a bit lighter on the hands, they often don’t match the dial. What Cal is this?

I would relume everything on the right.

 

Posts

1,567

Likes

12,406

Zapatta

·Oct 31, 2020

After seeing 1016, would go for both dial and hands! Just wow!

 

Posts

1,475

Likes

3,067

Diabolik

·Oct 31, 2020

Mark020

I know, I know: only original one. Fact is that the hands of this one are for sure not original lume and I have my doubts about the rest. Idea is to send the hands to James Hyman anyway but what about the rest. The longer I look at the lume the more doubts I have. Some pics: (also - for fun - James' recent work on a 1016)

I cannot praise James Hyman enough. He does a great job !

 

Posts

6,499

Likes

10,179

Mark020

·Oct 31, 2020·not the sharpest pencil in the ΩF drawer

bgrisso

What Cal is this?

285!

 

Posts

6,499

Likes

10,179

Mark020

·Oct 31, 2020·not the sharpest pencil in the ΩF drawer

bgrisso

Tough to say on the left, dial could be original lume. I would only relume the dial if the dark color really bothers you. You could probably go a bit lighter on the hands, they often don’t match the dial. What Cal is this?

I would relume everything on the right.

Right is no question for me: full relume.

 

Posts

3,587

Likes

8,281

bgrisso

·Oct 31, 2020

i have a set of these hands with orig lume, but it's for a cal 281, I assume the one on the left is larger diameter?

 

Posts

6,499

Likes

10,179

Mark020

·Oct 31, 2020·not the sharpest pencil in the ΩF drawer

Both are 36mm. James can perfectly match the hands and the dial.

 

Posts

2,710

Likes

17,411

jaguar11

·Oct 31, 2020

I would be tempted to go for all.

 

Posts

1,789

Likes

9,100

bubba48

·Oct 31, 2020

Don't touch the dial.

 

Posts

13,698

Likes

53,501

Larry S

·Nov 6, 2020·Color Commentator for the Hyperbole.

The dial is fair at best. The hands and the rest would make me nuts. Relume by a good practitioner plus a full service.

 

Posts

295

Likes

387

zwjk

·Nov 6, 2020

I would just leave UG as is. A relume would not match the patina of the dial and it would be an obvious relume.

However, it is a different story for the 1016 dial as it was in good condition in the first place albeit the lume was bad.

 

Posts

6,499

Likes

10,179

Mark020

·May 11, 2021·not the sharpest pencil in the ΩF drawer

Now back 🙄

 

Posts

1,178

Likes

4,217

Oku

·May 11, 2021

Colour is pretty close to originally aged 👍

For comparison:

 

Posts

870

Likes

2,386

jumpingsecond

·May 11, 2021

Relumed looks better 👍

 

Posts

210

Likes

123

JulianK

·May 11, 2021

Amazing result! There is definitely an argument to be made as well if lume isn't stable and/or flaking off.

 

Posts

3,587

Likes

8,281

bgrisso

·May 11, 2021

I think they look great, enjoy !

 

Posts

1,087

Likes

3,878

vujen

·May 14, 2021

I only see now this thread! Old lume looked ok to me, it should be radium.