Forums Latest Members

Adventures in Watch Collecting - What would you do?

  1. pitpro Likes the game. Apr 7, 2014

    Posts
    3,073
    Likes
    3,552
    I don't claim any knowledge about Zenith hallmarks or Lima
    watchmakers. Just pointing out that I thought Danomar had
    a good point that you overlooked in your explanation above him.
    The the circular grain doesn't pass through the hallmarks. That's
    obvious.
     
  2. LouS Mrs Nataf's Other Son Staff Member Apr 7, 2014

    Posts
    6,713
    Likes
    18,259
    Very simply - the circumferential graining is not standard factory caseback finish from either UG or Zenith on these gold chronographs. If you look on the image below you can see linear marks where the frankenizer went at the UG logo - looks like a mad slasher. The circumferential finish was added to camouflage the attack IMO. This is an aftermarket job.

    xxDSC_0109_zpsee5a4854.jpg
     
  3. pitpro Likes the game. Apr 7, 2014

    Posts
    3,073
    Likes
    3,552
    Yup, you pointed out the obliteration earlier. My comment was on the hallmarks.
     
  4. LouS Mrs Nataf's Other Son Staff Member Apr 7, 2014

    Posts
    6,713
    Likes
    18,259
    Ah. Well, I guess I don't perceive the hallmarks to be as sharp as you and danomar do. The details of Helvetia's face are completely effaced and the grain looks to have caught the hallmark edge as woodwrkr pointed out. I'm not sure I see anything to suggest the hallmarks were applied after the circumferential grind.
     
  5. pitpro Likes the game. Apr 7, 2014

    Posts
    3,073
    Likes
    3,552
    Zoom it up.
    Follow the lines from the left coming into the anvil.They are much fainter inside the anvil.
    Same with the head to a lesser extent.
    And there isn't even a line going into the
    nick in the back of the head. Looks like a hair detail to me.
     
  6. LouS Mrs Nataf's Other Son Staff Member Apr 7, 2014

    Posts
    6,713
    Likes
    18,259
    you're gonna make me go dig out my macro lens....
     
  7. pitpro Likes the game. Apr 7, 2014

    Posts
    3,073
    Likes
    3,552
    you're gonna make me go dig out my macro lens....

    you don't think that would make me change my mind, do you :)
    this Photoshop filter is called Emboss
    now what do you think?(but zoom it up good)
    All I did was add the filter.
    emboss.JPG
     
  8. woodwkr2 Apr 7, 2014

    Posts
    1,366
    Likes
    819
    I've explained how this was done, but okay...

    So you think the frankendoctor had passable hallmarking punches?
     
  9. woodwkr2 Apr 7, 2014

    Posts
    1,366
    Likes
    819
    So you've applied a machine algorithm that is specifically programmed to exaggerate hard edges. What does that prove?
     
  10. pitpro Likes the game. Apr 7, 2014

    Posts
    3,073
    Likes
    3,552
    the filter exaggerates all edges.
    but it looks the same to me without the
    filter. lines outside the anvil-
    barely anything inside it.
    no idea about the punches, not going there.
     
  11. Adam2941 Apr 15, 2014

    Posts
    216
    Likes
    288
    It's a beauty and I do not think the dial is a disaster. I like it. I like the whole watch just the way it is, Franken or not. Keep it, unless you only want "pure" watches in your collection (but can we ever be sure)?
     
  12. blackwatch wants tickets to the HyperBole. Apr 15, 2014

    Posts
    438
    Likes
    178
    Somebody would be happy with that watch. Not the last four buyers, maybe, but somebody. Let it go to that person.
     
  13. m neuman What, me worry? Apr 29, 2014

    Posts
    420
    Likes
    703
    What would be the reason to keep it?